After all the paint was off and I sanded it a little, I sprayed it with Rustoleum's Stone Grey in satin finish (spray paint and I are besties). It's a little darker than I wanted it but I can totally live with it.
Here is what I started with again if you didn't see my first post..
Then this is after the first round of many of the paint remover nightmare...
And one more time, the after..
Ahh..much better right?
See you soon!